Benriach "Importanticus Fumosus" (port finish) 12 y.o. 46%:
Very nice nose with fruit and wood smoke; rich palate with fruit
and smoke in a very nice balance; delicious, smoky finish
(89 p)
Benriach 1978 28 y.o. 54%:
Quiet, fruity and a little peaty nose; fruity and fairly sweet palate
with a very nice, mild peatiness
(87 p)
Benriach 1972 33 y.o. 45%:
Peaty, musty, fruity nose; complex, rich, dry palate, also oaky and spicy;
rather nice but a little too oaky
(87 p)
Bowmore 1994 b. 2006 (James MacArthur) 57.8%:
Peaty, malty nose with faint but nice fruity notes; light, very peaty palate
(87 p)
Caol Ila 1982 25 y.o. (James MacArthur) 55.5%:
Very nice, very unusual nose with iodine and a note of Trinidad rum; sweet, very nice
palate, also peaty with notes of fruit and arrack; quite peaty finish
(90 p)
Glendronach 8 y.o. (old dumpy bottle) 43%:
Wonderful fruity notes on the nose, also slightly peaty; mild, sweet and
a little spicy palate with notes of citrus fruits and banana
(90 p)
Glen Ord 1974 23 y.o. (Rare Malts) 60.8%:
Nice nose with the typical fruity character (banana, pear among other fruits);
nice, sweet, fruity palate, also a hint of peat
(87 p)
Glenury Royal 1971 23 y.o. (Rare Malts) 61.3%:
Very nice sherry on the nose with dried fruit, gingerbread and prunes; very nice, complex palate
with plums, gingerbread and wisps of smoke in the background; develops a note of mustard
(90 p)
Macallan 1969 (Murray McDavid "Mission") 41%:
Wonderful, intensely fruity nose with notes of melon and peach; fruity palate with oranges
and a chemical note like a good Armagnac, sweet but drying; dry, oaky, disappointing finish
(89 p)
Port Ellen 1983 22 y.o. (Douglas Laing) 50%:
Sweet palate with fresh fruity notes, also peaty with a very peaty finish
(88-89 p)
Springbank 1997 b. 2007 55.2%:
Very nice, very unusual nose; complex, sweet, fairly rich palate
with vanilla and tropical fruits, also peaty with quite a peaty finish
(87 p)